‘Downton Abbey’ Returns, With Every Splendid Soap Bubble Intact

Downton Abbey the television series is a tough act to follow.

Downton Abbey the movie does a jolly good job.

Carson returns. And so do we.

It opens in theaters Friday, which means “at long last” for fans who have been teased for three years by the tantalizing notion that their old favorite TV show might become their new favorite movie.

As it turns out, all those gorgeous visuals do look impressive on a big screen. But this also remains true: No matter how well the movie does, Downton will always in the hearts of its fans be a television show.

Artistically? Well, the several movie plotlines at times feel like a bit of a stretch, to which we say “So what?” because so did a number of the TV series plots. Mr. Pamuk, anyone?

No, Downton rose and soared on its characters, brilliantly developed by writer/creator Julian Fellowes and producer Gareth Neame and played beautifully by the large cast.

Downton is soap opera at its most satisfying, and all concerned have played it that way — deadly serious, with the occasional twinkle in their eyes.

The test for the movie, then, is whether Fellowes and Neame have kept the characters as we remember them, while allowing the incremental changes that life has a way of bringing about.

Short answer: They have. Hard-core fans who feared they might have to lament that “Mary would never do that” or “Carson would never say that” will be happily assuaged.

King George arrives and everyone lines up to say hi.

As the well-circulated previews have revealed, one foundation plotline has King George V (Simon Jones), his wife Queen Mary (Geraldine James) and their entourage visiting Downton.

This is quite the honor for Lord Grantham (Hugh Bonneville) and his American-born wife Cora (Elizabeth McGovern). It also triggers a chain of consequences, intended and unintended, that bring dramas into new bloom both upstairs and downstairs.

Fellowes skillfully uses these dramas to pick up many of the character threads he was following when the TV series ended.

After a lifetime of rejections and disappointments, second Crawley daughter Edith (Laura Carmichael) seemed to have finally hit the romance jackpot. Oldest daughter Mary (Michelle Dockery), who will inherit Downton, had married the handsome and dashing Henry (Matthew Goode).

Former driver Branson (Allen Leech) had opened an auto dealership and was helping Mary manage Downton. Head housekeeper Mrs. Hughes (Phyllis Logan) had married Carson (James Carter), who had retired and turned the butler position over to Thomas Barrow (Robert James-Collier), who seemingly had pulled his life together after a series of personal and professional disasters.

Kitchen maid Daisy (Sophie McShera) had a newfound confidence and seemingly an upward path, supported by head cook Mrs. Patmore (Lesley Nicol). Ladies’ maid Anna (Joanne Froggatt) and her valet husband Bates (Brendan Coyle) had their own place and a dream.

Up at the top, surveying it all, was acerbic Dowager Countess Violet (Maggie Smith), alongside her frequent companion and sparring partner, the gentler Isabel (Penelope Wilton).

The TV series, it’s important to note, didn’t end with cliffhangers. It ended rather peacefully, with no one of the brink of anything ominous — except possibly Downton itself, which like other British manor estates was facing the increasing possibility that it could become unsustainable.

We viewers know this specter will soon become a crisis, thanks to the Great Depression and another World War. But Downton The Movie is set only the year after the TV series ended, so none of that yet comes into play.

Which is fine, because it enables Fellowes to focus not on an increasingly awful world, but on lives we felt part of.

At the risk of mild spoilers, fans of Branson and the plucky downstairs staff may be particularly pleased. So will Violet fans, as she gets not only her expected volley of clever repartee, but a critical plotline.

Fellowes might have shown a bit more restraint with Mr. Molesley (Kevin Doyle), but then, Mr. Molesley once tried to look younger by rubbing shoe polish into his hair. So there’s precedent.

In general, knowing the TV series will make the movie richer and considerably more nuanced. That said, you don’t have pass a test to understand what’s happening on the screen.

Fellowes inserts a handful of new characters, notably Lady Maud Bagshaw (Imelda Staunton) and Lucy Smith (Tuppence Middleton) (no relation to the real-life contemporary Duchess of Cambridge). Both play pivotal roles in a subplot that subtly harks back to the beginning of the first TV season.

Like the passionate fans of any long-running TV show, Downton aficionados will doubtless find moments and details both to question and to to single out for praise. In the latter vein, there’s a brief closing scene on a balcony that should get a place on any Downton highlight reel.

Edith, Violet, Lord and Lady Granthm.

On the surface, Downton Abbey the movie might seem like a second goodbye. Somehow it doesn’t, and not just because we’ve heard hints that if this movie does well, there could be another.

Rather, the movie reinforces the unspoken sense that this story will continue long after it’s no longer being dramatized.

That’s one of the reasons we like it.

David Hinckley wrote for the New York Daily News for 35 years. Now he drives his wife crazy by randomly quoting Bob Dylan and “Casablanca.”

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store